WHICH DO YOU PICK?

This past Sunday, my husband, Erik, preached on Psalm 92. This Psalm is focused on the Sabbath, resting in the Lord, and giving Him thanks for all He has done.

There were several things that Erik said that jumped out to me and got scribbled into my pocket notebook, but the one that I’ve been thinking about today is a doozey.

Are you ready for it?

“Gratitude and control are opposing.”

Now he didn’t say that explicitly, but that’s what I read into what he said at the end of the sermon, which was, “You can choose gratitude or you can choose control.”

That “or” really got me. Can’t I do both? Turns out, not very well.

Gratitude, in and of itself, is directed outward. It’s thanks for what someone else has done for you. Control, of course, is focused inward. It’s all about what you can, have, or should do for yourself. They really are opposing!

So that got me thinking…do I spent more time giving thanks of trying to control my life?

Without a doubt, my scale tips wildly towards control.

  • I wake up in the morning thinking about what I’m going to do that day rather than thanking God for the day He has created and letting Him guide me.
  • I plan out my meals, running to the store to fill in one missing ingredient rather than thanking God for my full fridge and giving Him thanks for what He has already provided.
  • I have a running checklist in my mind of what I’m going to do next rather than giving God thanks for each moment and seeing where He leads and what He invites me to do.

I could go on and on, but I think you get the picture. And while there is nothing inherently bad about planning our days, our budgets, and our shopping trips (after all, they allow us to steward what we’ve been given well), I confess that, for me, I do those things not to honor the Lord but to try to control my own life.

But what if, instead, I chose to focus not on what I can do but rather what God has done, and is doing? What if I find a way to give Him thanks in every situation rather than trying to control it?

Want an example of how this plays out?

Last week, I had an endoscopy. It’s the 4th one I’ve had (I have IBS and some very “fun” digestive issues, which I have struggled with for over 20 years). As I was waking up, the doctor came in and said, “You’ve got some small spots of erosion. They’ll heal on their own. I took some biopsies. We’ll see what those results show.”

With that, he was gone, and as I went home, I was frustrated.

I had the exact same diagnosis over three years ago when I had this procedure. At the time, I was told it was probably from the aspirin I’d been taking daily since I had a heart attack. So, I talked to my cardiologist and switched to something that would be gentler on my stomach. I also started taking prescription acid reducers, which I’ve taken regularly for the last three years. All that to say, I was doing everything I could to get my stomach to heal and protect it, and yet, here I was, still with erosion.

So what did I do with my frustration? I jumped onto the ever-helpful internet and started searching for what else I could do to get my stomach lining to heal. If what the doctor had told me hadn’t worked, surely there was more that I could do. Surely there was another way I could control the problem and control my symptoms.

That night, I turned to Erik and told him how frustrated I was. He looked at me and said, “I get it. But instead of focusing on what’s wrong, why don’t you spend some time giving God thanks? I’m thankful that while you still have erosion, it’s not worse. It’s not something major. It’s not cancer. It’s not Crohn’s disease. I know it doesn’t feel like it right now, but this is good news.”

Essentially, he was telling me to live out 1 Thessalonians 5:18, which says. “Give thanks in all circumstances; for this is God’s will for you in Christ Jesus.”

The next day, I pulled out my journal and listed the things I had to be grateful for related to my diagnosis. It didn’t solve everything, but it did help. More importantly, it reminded me that while my go-to is always to try to grasp for control, God is inviting me to something else.

He is inviting me to rest in Him, trust Him, and give Him thanks for what He’s doing. He’s inviting me to believe that He’s going to take care of me better than I could ever take care of myself.

Even though I’ve seen Him do this in my life countless times, including during our recent trip to Hawaii, it’s still a struggle for me. And I’m now realizing that maybe part of my struggle was that I’ve tried to control even my gratitude by putting rules around it like, “You have to give thanks before you eat,” and “Make sure you write down at least three things you’re thankful for every day.”

Part of me felt like if I could just do those things — if I could just control my gratitude — then I’d stop struggling and live in constant joy.

Turns out, because I was still trying to control it (and thus was focusing on myself), I wasn’t able to experience the full depth of God’s goodness or express gratitude in a way that would change everything about my life — even in hard situations.

I’m not the first one to think about this. Ann Voskamp wrote an amazing book about gratitude called One Thousand Gifts, as have countless theologians and even some self-help counselors. But the example that sticks out to me the most comes from Corrie Ten Boom’s book, The Hiding Place.

At the time, Corrie and her sister, Betsie, are at Ravensbrück concentration camp (their family had been arrested for hiding Jews in their home during the Nazi occupation of Holland). At first, Corrie doesn’t think there is anything to be grateful for, but Betsie helps her see that even in that horrible, evil place, God was giving them plenty of things to praise Him for.

They go on to list several things, including the fact that they’re imprisoned together, they still have their Bible, that because there are so many women crammed in with them, they’ll have a chance to share the Gospel with a lot of people. And then, Betsie gives thanks for the fleas that are swarming them and biting into their flesh. It’s too much for Corrie. Fleas? There is nothing good about fleas! But Betsie insists.

Months later, they find out the reason they can be so grateful for that infestation of fleas. It turns out the fleas had kept the guards out of their quarters, giving them more freedom and protecting them from falling prey to the horrific fate other women who hadn’t been surrounded by fleas.

Something that seemed so horrible was actually God’s gift!

I think in our culture, where technology allows us to the illusion of control over so much of our lives, we forget that being in control isn’t the answer. In fact, by focusing on control, we often miss out on practicing gratitude, which not only is better for our health (countless studies have been published about how giving thanks can be healing), but it puts us back where we were always supposed to be: walking with the Lord.

Is it easy? No.

But as we head into the week of Thanksgiving, it’s certainly something to be mindful of, and to practice. I’m going to. I hope you will, too.